7 Comments
User's avatar
Peter's avatar

Great article. What do you think about Otto Weininger and supposedly killing himself because of “his jewishness”?

Expand full comment
Karl's avatar

I have an article coming about Weininger!

Expand full comment
Wardellgray's avatar

Well, also Gilad Atzmon is an 'ex jew' but he's a great individual.

Anyway, just a question, is this article translated in english with some tool? It's written in a strange english.

Expand full comment
Res Cogitans's avatar

Very intriguing article, though I will say, having read Freedman's work, I did not come away with the impression that he considered Jews/Jewishness purely as a religious affiliation. He did seem to treat that as the major factor in the bulk of cohesive Jewish behavior & identity, but I gathered that he understood and acknowledged the genetic factor as well, otherwise the foray into Khazar and Eastern European admixture origins of the Ashkenazi would have been pointless. Other than that, excellent article casting doubt on Freedman's claims. Also, side note - It looks like blogspot killed the link to the older article.

Expand full comment
Hunter James's avatar

Karl, thanks for all your work. Just a heads up that the url in footnote #24 is no longer valid.

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Mar 23
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
CK's avatar

To be fair to Unz, I don’t think he moderates comments on the site and there’s a lot of jew pilling over there.

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Mar 23
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
Hunter James's avatar

Agree. I don't know Ron's motives but he is at least willing to have both essays and comment section more open to "free speech". It's getting harder and harder to find forums where true though diversity is allowed.

The 8200 trolls are rather obvious tho, and makes for some funny comments to be sure.

Expand full comment