Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Dionysios Dionou's avatar

Excellent essay I'd enjoy essays regarding Genrikh Yagoda and Nicholai Yezhov too.

Expand full comment
Afshin Nejat's avatar

We can apply the adage that one should do what one loves and never work a day in one's life. "Legitimate enjoyment" also says a lot. It's as if corruption has its own version of a worldview which is as Thrasymachus would have it: Justice (perhaps "what is fitting") is in the interest of the stronger. Very anti-Platonic and anti-idealistic, to think that all lines between actions are drawn not by the distinction between virtue and vice, but by the sole question of who has the power to get away with something. "Might makes right" they seem to say.

They don't usually ever say this part out loud when they push to legitimize their power in the eyes of the masses that they manipulate, but it is quietly stated in how they flatter the same masses into thinking that their sheer numbers justify their own power. I would say this is the linchpin, an appeal to brute force, but it still flatters itself for it rests on the presumption that the use of such power is not to destroy any elite or aristocracy really, but to destroy any corruption, or irredeemable lack of virtue, residing in comfort and safety under the guise of aristocracy (hence the hateful thought about the middle class expressed in the term "bourgeoisie").

Then what do these unfortunate throngs get? Exactly what they were promised to be rid of, corrupt monsters lording over them.

Expand full comment
3 more comments...

No posts